When Science Was Wrong: The Times They Got it Wrong

A look at some of the most glaring examples where science was wrong, and the repercussions of these errors.

Checkout this video:


Sometimes, scientists get it wrong. They make mistakes, miscalculate, or misinterpret data. Thankfully, the scientific process is designed to catch errors and allow for new theories to be proposed when old ones are proven inaccurate. In this article, we explore some of the most famous times when science was wrong.

The Times They Got It Wrong: Science Edition

In 1633, Galileo Galilei was convicted of heresy by the Catholic Church for challenging the consensus that the sun revolved around the earth. In 1865, a young doctor named Ignaz Semmelweis was dismissed from his job at a Viennese hospital for suggesting that doctors wash their hands before delivering babies, a practice that would later save countless lives. These are just two examples of science getting it wrong, but eventually getting it right.

In this article, we’ll explore some more examples of when science was wrong, including:
– The 4-minute mile
– Cold Fusion
– The Curvature of the Earth
– The Expanding Universe
– Plate Tectonics
– continental drift
So please, read on and enjoy stepping into a world where our current scientific consensus may someday be viewed as “wrong.”

Why Does Science Get It Wrong?

With all the current talk about “fake news,” it’s more important than ever to be able to distinguish between fact and fiction. Unfortunately, even the most reputable sources can sometimes get it wrong. When it comes to science, this is especially true. In the past, many scientific breakthroughs were later proved to be false. So why does science get it wrong?

There are a number of reasons why science sometimes gets it wrong. First, our understanding of the world is constantly changing as we learn more. Second, new technology can sometimes change the way we see things. Third, scientists are human, and like all humans, they sometimes make mistakes.

Despite these shortcomings, science is still the best tool we have for understanding the world around us. Scientists are constantly trying to improve their methods so that they can get closer to the truth. As our understanding of the world grows, so does our ability to correct our mistakes.

The Times Science Got It Wrong: A History

Science is never wrong, but sometimes scientists are. In this column, we explore the times when science got it wrong, and what we can learn from these mistakes.

Humans are naturally curious creatures. We want to know why the leaves change color in fall, why the sun rises in the east and sets in the west, and how long it will take for that scab on our knee to heal. This curiosity has led us to some of the most important discoveries in history.

But for every time we’ve gotten it right, there have been just as many times when science got it wrong. In this column, we’ll explore some of those times, and what we can learn from them.

One of the most famous examples of science getting it wrong is the case of Galileo Galilei. Galileo was a Italian scientist who lived in the 1600s. He is considered one of the Fathers of Modern Science for his work in physics, astronomy, and mathematics. He made many important discoveries, such as proving that objects of different masses fall at the same rate, and discovering the four largest moons of Jupiter. He also developed one of the first telescopes.

However, Galileo also made some errors in his work. One famous example is his theory that objects made of different materials fall at different rates. This theory was later disproven by experiments conducted by English scientist Isaac Newton.

Another famous example of science getting it wrong is the case of phrenology. Phrenology was a pseudoscience that was popular in the 1800s and early 1900s. Phrenologists believed that they could determine a person’s personality traits and abilities by feeling bumps on their head. This theory was eventually debunked by scientific research which found no correlation between head bumps and personality traits.

These are just a few examples of times when science got it wrong. But each time scientists have made a mistake, they have also learned from it and grown wiser as a result. So even though science may sometimes get it wrong, we can always learn from our mistakes and continue moving forward in our quest to understand our world better

The Times Science Got It Wrong: A Timeline

science has been wrong before. In fact, it’s been wrong multiple times. Here’s a timeline of some of the most prominent times science got it wrong.

-In the year 451 AD, the Roman Empire believed that diseases were caused by an imbalance of the four humors: black bile, yellow bile, phlegm, and blood.
-In the early 1800s, some doctors believed that “animal heat” was responsible for many diseases and that bleeding patients would cure them.
-In 1846, Ignaz Semmelweis discovered that washing hands with chlorine could prevent the spread of disease in hospitals but his finding was not accepted by the medical community for decades.
-In 1896, X-rays were thought to be a cure for cancer but we now know that they can cause cancer.
-In the early 1900s, many physicians believed that pellagra was caused by a germ and could be cured with hospitalization and isolation. We now know that pellagra is caused by a deficiency in niacin.
-In 1938, Dr. Stirling Boyd performed an experiment in which he injected live cancer cells into mice to see if they would grow. The mice did not get cancer and Boyd concluded that cancer was not contagious. This experiment influenced cancer treatment for years to come.
-Between the 1950s and 1970s, many psychiatric patients were treated with lobotomies in an attempt to “cure” them. We now know that lobotomies are ineffective and can cause serious damage to patients.
-In 1957, the U.S. Public Health Service conducted a study on 400 poor black men with syphilis in Tuskegee, Alabama. The men were told they were being treated for “bad blood” but were actually left untreated so researchers could study the course of the disease. This unethical study caused great harm to these men and their families.

The Times Science Got It Wrong: The Cases

In the late 19th century, science seemed to be getting everything right. In a matter of decades, electricity, the telephone, automobiles and airplanes had been invented and perfected. But for every Eureka moment, there were countless failures. Scientists were constantly discovering new things that contradicted what they had previously thought to be true.

Here are some of the most infamous times science got it wrong:

-In the early 1800s, scientists believed that disease was caused by bad smells, or “miasma.” This led to some pretty disgusting medical practices, like using leeches and bloodletting to “purify” patients’ blood.
-In the mid-19th century, scientists thought that mental illness was caused by a excess of black bile in the brain. This led to some pretty barbaric treatments, like public lobotomies and hydrotherapy.
-In the early 20th century, scientists believed that homosexuality was caused by a deficiency of testosterone. This led to some pretty horrific “cures,” like castration and electroshock therapy.
-In the mid-20th century, scientists believed that intelligence was primarily determined by genetics. This led to some pretty abhorrent social policies, like eugenics and segregated schools.
-In the late 20th century, scientists believed that ulcers were caused by stress. This led to some pretty ineffective treatments, like antacids and stress management classes.

The Times Science Got It Wrong: The Aftermath

While most times science gets it right, there have been many occasions where they have gotten it wrong. In some cases, the scientific community was quick to correct their mistake and move on. Other times, the incorrect theory became widely accepted and it took years for the truth to be revealed. Occasionally, the wrong theory persists even after being proven false.

The Times Science Got It Wrong: The Aftermath
Incorrect theories can cause a lot of harm. Lives have been lost, careers ruined, and entire industries destroyed when science gets it wrong. Here are some notable examples of when science got it wrong and the aftermath that followed.

1) Bleeding as a medical treatment- For centuries, bloodletting was considered a viable medical treatment. Doctors would remove large quantities of blood from their patients in an attempt to cure them of various diseases. It wasn’t until the 20th century thatbleeding as a medical treatment was finally debunked.

2) The belief that objects in space are indestructible- For many years, scientists believed that objects in space were made of an indestructible material called “ether”. This theory was eventually disproven by Einstein’s theory of relativity.

3) The existence of “phlogiston”- Phlogiston was a hypothetical substance that was believed to be responsible for combustion. This theory was accepted for almost two centuries before it was finally disproven in the late 18th century.

4) The use of X-rays as a beauty treatment- In the early 20th century, X-rays were touted as a miracle beauty treatment that could remove wrinkles and make skin look younger. It wasn’t until decades later that the harmful effects of radiation were properly understood and X-rays were no longer used for this purpose

The Times Science Got It Wrong: The Implications

While it’s easy to assume that everything we know is correct, history has shown us time and time again that this is not the case. In fact, many of the things we take for granted today as scientific knowledge were once considered little more than speculation. It’s only through the advancement of technology and further research that we’ve been able to prove or disprove certain theories.

However, even with all of our advancements, there are still times when science gets it wrong. While this may not always have major implications, there have been moments in history where getting it wrong had far-reaching consequences. Here are a few times when science was wrong and the implications thereof.

In the early 1800s, scientist John Dalton theorized that all elements were made up of atoms that were indivisible and indestructible. This theory went unchallenged for nearly 50 years until another scientist, J.J. Thomson, discovered electrons – particles that were much smaller than atoms. This discovery led to the development of quantum mechanics and opened up a whole new world of possibilities in terms of what atoms could do.

In 1927, German physicist Werner Heisenberg developed the uncertainty principle which stated that it was impossible to know both the momentum and position of an electron at the same time. This theory was widely accepted for many years and had a major impact on the way scientists viewed subatomic particles. It wasn’t until 1954 that another physicist, Richard Feynman, developed a different theory that explained Heisenberg’s findings without the need for an uncertainty principle.

Perhaps one of the most famous examples of science getting it wrong is with respect to Pluto. In 1930, astronomer Clyde Tombaugh discovered Pluto after days of painstaking observations. For years Pluto was considered to be the ninth planet in our solar system but then in 2006 things changed. After further observation, scientists concluded that Pluto was not a planet but rather a “dwarf planet” – a classification that is still disputed by some today.

These are just a few examples of times when science got it wrong but they serve to show us that nothing is set in stone and what we know today could be proven wrong tomorrow

The Times Science Got It Wrong: The Lessons

From the invention of the lightbulb to the discovery of Antarctica, nothing has been free of trial and error. Times when science got it wrong are important to remember so we can learn from past mistakes.

Some of the most famous times science got it wrong include:
-In 1873, Elisha Gray filed a patent for the telephone, just hours after Alexander Graham Bell. The patent was ultimately awarded to Bell.
-In 1876, Nikola Tesla invented the AC induction motor, but because he was working for Thomas Edison at the time, Edison took all the credit.
-In 1902, Wilhelm Röntgen won the Nobel Prize in Physics for his discovery of X-rays. However, he didn’t actually discover them–he was just the first to study their effects and applications.

These are just a few examples of when science got it wrong. Even though these inventors and scientists were not given credit for their discoveries at the time, their legacy lives on and we continue to benefit from their work.


In conclusion, science is not an exact science. There will always be times when scientists are wrong. However, that doesn’t mean that science is a bad thing. Science is constantly evolving, and as new evidence is found, old theories are often disproved. The important thing is to always question what you know and to never take anything for granted.

Scroll to Top